commentopia

Curating the Best Comments from Top News Sites and Blogs

Courtesy Facebook's Facebook page

PLANET FACEBOOK

 

WORLD    NATIONAL    BUSINESS    HEALTH/EDUCATION    SCI/TECH    ENVIRONMENT    SPORTS/ENTERTAINMENT    PEOPLE

WORLD

Greece Closer to a Moment of Truth

Anyone who thought the Greek bailout plan was actually going to work was either under-informed or delusional, and certain pan-European leaders seem to be both. To expect the kind of growth necessary for it to work (7 percent/year) while also cutting spending from the biggest spender in the country sounds like something from Kurt Vonnegut. I sincerely hope there is a back-up plan written somewhere for the withdrawal of Greece from the Eurozone that is designed to function on reality instead of hopes and dreams, as the current bailout package is.

READ MORE  •••

49 Decapitated Bodies Found Near Mexican Border

President Felipe Calderón

It is true that, according to some estimates, 70 percent of the weapons used by Mexican drug gangs are smuggled across the American border and that the U.S. must do much more to stop the illegal gun trade. It is also true that American demand for narcotics fuels Mexico’s drug business. But if easy access to guns were the cause of Mexico’s predicament, then Texas would be as lawless as Chihuahua. If a border with the U.S. drug market were the problem, then Canada would also be fighting such gangs.


So if Mexico’s internal strife is not an insurgency and not primarily the U.S.’s fault, what is it? One possibility is that it is the result of decades-long corrupt and incompetent government, popular contempt for the rule of law, a weak civil society and a growing gap between rich and poor. These conditions created a state that is unable to enforce its laws, provide services or opportunities for its poorer citizens, or create a sense of community across regional or class boundaries. Seen this way, the current drug violence might be a symptom of more fundamental problems afflicting Mexican society.

READ MORE  •••

MEXICAN DRUG WAR IN PICTURES

Saving Sergeant Bergdahl - Grassroots Movement Grows to Bring Taliban Captive Home

Thank you for reporting on SGT Bergdahl. I've always felt SGT Berdahl has been ignored largely by the media, and at times it would seem our government, and I can only surmise that this is because his story doesn't interest people or can't be manipulated to further some political agenda. While almost everybody's heard of Pat Tillman, or Jessica Lynch, or even protestor Cindy Sheehan and her deceased son Casey, nobody is talking about Bowe Bergdahl.

Had it not been for the social media and a friend sharing his story, I probably would not have heard of him either. But yet here he is, living in captivity, in either reportedly Pakistan or Afghanistan and there seems no sense of urgency of getting the man back home. If we can get Osama Bin Laden, how come we cannot get this man home who has now been held captive for over 3 years? Could it be that he isn't known because there is no cool story to sell? Is he too ordinary that the press won't focus on him? Had he gotten the media attention that the others received, would he have been brought home? One has to ask these questions because Jessica Lynch was retrieved relatively quickly compared to what's going on with Bowe Berdahl.

Unlike Cindy Sheehan or Pat Tilman's family and their outrage, SGT Berdahl's family has largely shied away from media attention. As his father has stated, they are quiet in public but loud behind the scenes. Regardless of whether you agree with the war or not, this man Bowe Robert Bergdahl is somebody's son. He's young, at 26, and deserves at least the chance of a full, fruitful and prosperous life: the pursuit of happiness we are all entitled to.

READ MORE  •••

Taking Credit for Bin Laden's Death

The classic false equivalency here - "Geroge W Bush and Obama are both militarily aggressive" - hides the truth, as it always does when it's wheeled out. We on the non-existent "left" might not agree with his choices all the time, but at least he's using force *intelligently.* He applies surgical precision to very targeted attack: Bin Laden is attacked, not Pakistan; individual Al Qaeda leaders are taken out, Yemen and Somalia are not occupied.

This has always been the way the "war on terror" should have been a fought: a shadowy war of intelligence and counter-intelligence and covert, surgical strikes against individuals. In contrast, Bush stormed into Iraq for no good reason and cost hundreds of thousands of lives and untold billions in useless spending.

The equivalence between the two, as implied in the sixth paragraph of the piece, is false.

READ MORE  •••

The Great Ship RMS Titanic - A World Remembers and Reflects

As the anniversary of Titanic's sinking arrives tomorrow, I've had opportunity to reflect on these stories of grace under pending doom that keep emerging.

Just a couple of years ago, while doing some genealogical research, I came across a relative who died in the Titanic tragedy: Wallace Henry Hartley, the young violinist who led the eight-member orchestra on the doomed ship.

Wallace, my distant cousin, and his fellow musicians are credited by most accounts with keeping the passengers calm by doing what they did best: playing music. It may seem like a useless thing to do in what was imaginably a scene of increasing horror and chaos but in the words of several survivors, it was seen as an act of grace --- there was no way that these eight men nor any of the others could be saved once the last lifeboat had been released and so, whether out of acceptance, duty or just as a means of distracting themselves from the inevitable, Wallace and his fellow young musicians played music.

All of these men were young --- Wallace was the oldest. The youngest was 20. Wallace was engaged to be married. At least two left widows and one didn't know that he was about to be a father. Legend has it their last song was "Nearer, My God, to Thee." 

READ MORE  •••



advertisement

Uys has accomplished what no Brazilian author from José de Alencar to Jorge Amado was able to do. He is the first to write our national epic in all its decisive episodes, from the indigenous civilization and the El Dorado myth, everything converging like the segments of a rose window to that reborn and metamorphosed myth that is Brasilia.

He is the first outsider to see us with total honesty and sympathy and full empathy with the decisive moments in our history and their spiritual meaning. Descriptions like those of the war with Paraguay are unsurpassed in our literature and evoke the great passages of War and Peace. Wilson Martins, Jornal do Brasil

A masterpiece! Brazil has the feel of an enchanted virgin forest, a totally new and original world for the reader-explorer to discover. L' Express, Paris

Pulsing with vigor, this is a vast novel to tell the story of a vast country. Uys recreates history almost entirely "at ground level," through the eyes and actions of an awesome cast of characters. Publishers Weekly

PRINT & E-BOOK

 


SCI|TECH

Facebook Update: Share Your Status --And Your Organs

 

I don't have any objection to organ donation whatosever -- in fact I am on the organ and bone marrow transplant lists. What I object to is Facebook attempting to get its tentacles into yet another area of our private lives for its own gain.

I might be cynical, but they have form. Everything they do is for the supposedly laudable aim of creating 'connections' but the truth is that you are nothing more to them than a tiny slice of their 900-million-strong product offering. I don't want any part of my life, much less something as important as my decision whether or not to donate my organs, being a part of their attempt to reduce every human being on the planet to a saleable Facebook profile.

I'm all for raising awareness of the issue, absolutely. And I can see why Facebook is an obvious means of doing so. But that doesn't make it the right place for it. I'd rather see awareness being increased through other means less tied with commercial ends.

READ MORE •••

Will Asteroid Mining Fuel a New Age of Discovery?

By far the most readily available workable asteroid mineral is plain old ordinary water, and the designated target asteroids are 40% water by mass. Properly (and easily) refined in space this water becomes an equal mass of LH2/LO2 (liquid hydrogen and oxygen), also known as "rocket fuel", in a near-zero g environment. Kilotons of the stuff. It makes nice drinking water and breathable air too, and it might be possible in the longer term to actually grow produce in space to provide food and provisions to humans, though this is a minor impact over the fuel issue. ...

If you have a robotic rocket fuel factory in high lunar orbit you can sell its output to people who want to do things in space at a considerable profit. You can then fuel robotic lunar landing craft to collect more water to refine from the lunar poles until you have unlimited fuel. You don't even have to claim you own this space produce (a political sticky point): you can charge for delivery and processing only. You can fuel, for example, manned trips to Mars the quick way rather than the slow way, and ensure that it's a round trip rather than a one-way trip. You can even send robotic fuel ships in advance to await the human mission in orbit around Mars, or anywhere else in the solar system.

READ MORE •••


 

U.S. PRINT SOURCES

ARIZONA REPUBLIC

ATLANTA JOURNAL-CONST.

BALTIMORE SUN

BOSTON GLOBE
BOSTON HERALD

CHICAGO SUN-TIMES
CHICAGO TRIBUNE
CHRISTIAN SCIENCE-

MONITOR

CLEVELAND PLAIN- DEALER

DALLAS MORNING- NEWS

DENVER POST

DETROIT FREE PRESS

FINANCIAL TIMES
FORBES

FORTUNE

HOLLYWOOD REPORTER

HOUSTON CHRONICLE
INVESTORS BUSINESS DAILY

INDIANAPOLIS STAR

KANSAS CITY STAR
L0S ANGELES TIMES

MIAMI HERALD

MILWAUKEE JOURNAL- SENTINEL

MINNEAPOLIS STAR- TRIBUNE

NATION
NATIONAL ENQUIRER
NATIONAL REVIEW
NEW JERSEY STAR-LEDGER

NEW REPUBLIC

NEW YORK

NEW YORK DLY NEWS
NEW YORK OBSERVER
NEW YORK POST
NEW YORK TIMES
NEW YORKER
NEWSWEEK

OREGONIAN

ORANGE COUNTY- REGISTER

ORLANDO SENTINEL
PEOPLE
PHILADELPHIA- INQUIRER
PHILADELPHIA DAILY NEWS

PITTSBURGH POST-GAZETTE

REASON MAG
ROLLING STONE

SACRAMENTO BEE

SAN ANTONIO EXP- NEWS

SAN DIEGO UNION-TRIB
SAN FRANCISCO- CHRONICLE

SAN JOSE MERCURY- NEWS
STAR

ST. LOUIS POST- DISPATCH

ST.PETERSBURG- TIMES
TIME

U.S. NEWS
USA TODAY
VANITY FAIR
VARIETY

VILLAGE VOICE

WALL STREET JNL
WASHINGTON POST
WASHINGTON TIMES
WEEKLY STANDARD

WIRED

INTL. PRINT SOURCES

AUSTRALIAN

CANADA GLOBE & MAIL

CANADA NATL POST

DER SPIEGEL INTL.

INDIA TIMES

INTL. HERALD TRIBUNE

IRISH TIMES

JERUSALEM POST

JOHANNESBURG STAR

KENYA DAILY NATION

MOSCOW TIMES

PAKISTAN DAWN

PAKISTAN NEWS INTL.

PRAVDA

S.A. MAIL&GUARDIAN

S.AFRICA TIMES

SYDNEY MORNING HERALD

TORONTO STAR

TORONTO SUN
[U.K.] DAILY MAIL
[U.K.] DAILY MIRROR
[U.K.] DAILY RECORD

[U.K.] ECONOMIST
[U.K.] EVENING STANDARD
[U.K.] EXPRESS
[U.K.] GUARDIAN
[U.K.] INDEPENDENT
[U.K.] NEWS OF THE WORLD

[U.K.] NEW STATESMAN

[U.K.] SCOTSMAN

[U.K.] SPECTATOR
[U.K.] SUN
[U.K.] TELEGRAPH
[U.K.] TIMES

VANCOUVER SUN

RADIO AND TV

ABC NEWS

AL JAZEERA

BBC
BBC VIDEO & AUDIO

BBC WORLD SERVICE

BLOOMBERG

CBC NEWS
CBS NEWS

CITADEL- BROADCASTING

CLEAR CHANNEL- RADIO
C-SPAN
CNN

CNN VIDEO & AUDIO

DAILY SHOW

ESPN
EW ENTERTAINMENT- WEEKLY
FOXNEWS
MSNBC

NPR

PBS

SKY NEWS

THE WIRES

AFP via YAHOO

AP WORLD
AP NATIONAL

AP NEWS VIDEO

BUSINESS NEWS WIRE

INDIA-ASIA NEWS

INTERFAX

INTERNET NEWS

ITAR-TASS RUSSIA

KYODO JAPAN

MCCLATCHY

MERCOPRESS

NASDAQ HEADLINES

N.Y. TIMES WIRE

REUTER'S

UPI

ZINHAU CHINA NEWS

THE WEB

ALL AFRICA

ARS TECHNICA

BOING-BOING

BREITBART

BUSINESS INSIDER

BUZZ FEED

BUZZ MACHINE  

CONSERVATIVE BLOG

DAILY BEAST

DAILY HOWLER
DAILY KOS
DAILY SWARM

DRUDGE REPORT

E! ONLINE

FREE REPUBLIC

GAWKER

GLOBAL POST

GOOGLE NEWS

HOT AIR

HUFFINGTON POST

IAFRICA

ISRAEL NEWS

LUCIANNE.COM

MOTLEY FOOL

MY WAY

NEWSLOOK
NEWSMAX

ONION

POLITICAL WIRE

POLITICO

PROPUBLICA

RADAR

REALCLEAR POLITICS

REUTER'S BLOGS

ROLL CALL

SALON

SEATTLE POST INTELLIGENCER

SLATE

SMOKING GUN
SPLASH NEWS

TALKING POINTS MEM

TECHCRUNCH

THE HILL

TMZ

TOPIX

WORLDNETDAILY

WOWOWOW

YAHOO NEWS

YOUTUBE

WEATHER CHANNEL

WORLD WEATHER FORECASTS

NEWSMAP

WORLD NEWSPAPERS ONLINE

WORLD FRONT PAGES

NATIONAL

Same-Sex Marriage: Evolution of a President

Always trying to keep an open mind, I like to be to see both sides of an issue, because only then can I make an informed decision. However try as I might I cannot see a plausible argument against same sex marriage.

As a heterosexual Christian male, same sex marriage does not affect me. It not as if the newlyweds will be living in my kitchen! The only argument against same sex marriage I’ve heard is that passages in the bible forbid it. So what! The decisions of others don’t affect my holy divinity.

And last time I checked America had a separate church and state, so why are religious policies holding sway over social issues? Can someone please prove me wrong? Show me a valid argument against same-sex marriage.

READ MORE •••

 

Pew: Receding Tide of Illegal Immigrants from Mexico

PEW RESEARCH CENTER REPORT

One can argue about the actual numbers of illegals in the US but, the truth is, no one really knows.

What is accurate is that the flow of illegals from México to the US has slowed almost to a trickle. How do I know? We live here, just about 100km south of the border on one of the main smuggling routes.

We use to see dozens of "pollos" every day passing through. Now, very few, if any, can be seen. The little pueblo of Altar, perhaps the busiest of all the jumping off points is a ghost town.

The cartels have even stopped killing each other as there is little to fight about.

Argue all you want. We live it every day and it has virtually stopped.

Will it start again someday? Perhaps, but I doubt it will ever reach the numbers of the past years for all the reasons in the article. México is a very different country than it was even just 10 years ago.

READ MORE •••

 

Secret Service Scandal Tarnishes Reputation of Agency

Born 60 years ago in the Elite NYC suburb of Short Hills, and raised there, and living a career as executive in the computer industry leading elite teams to turn around failing organizations for 30 years, I know excellence. I know talent. I've led, worked with, our best from Harvard, Yale, MIT, Stanford....

For the last 10 years I've had the privilege of logging 1000's of hours watching, and being watched by the Secret Service in DC. By orders of magnitude this is the most stunning group of human beings I've ever seen, read of, heard of.... Unimaginable, impossible, if I'd not seen it with my own eyes. Courageous, disciplined, mature, professional, kind, decent, unbreakable, proud, honorable, immensely intelligent. I would take a bullet for any of these folks. You should too, starting now, the bullets launched at them by the ignorant rock throwers throughout our sick society.

READ MORE •••


HEALTH/EDUCATION

Weight of the Nation: Sizing Up the Big Report on Obesity in America

One part of the solution is a tax which squarely put accountability for the obesity epidemic on the makers and consumers of such foods, which is a level of personal responsibility via targetted taxation that a rational conservative should applaud.

You may also note, the other major solution is a major cut in federal spending in terms of cutting farm subsidies for unhealthy foods.

That said, while I agree that all of these environmental factors are important contributing factors to the obesity epidemic, I think it is not appropriate to take the emphasis off of personal responsibility. Very few obese, overweight people are that way “naturally” due to “big bones” and “glandular problems”, most of them are that way because they have no self-control, and everything is everyone else’s fault, and enabling that attitude is very unhealthy.

Here is a great tip for losing weight from someone currently having some success moving back towards my college weight from a peak late 20′s/early 30′s “bloat”: don’t get on the scale, don’t count calories, don’t listen to or rely on gimmickry and for god sakes don’t wait for the government to help. Just eat less and excercise more. Repeat, Repeat, Repeat.

READ MORE •••

The More You Sleep, the Less You Weigh? - Study

All this is true. I observed the same thing and came up with my own conclusion about this idea years ago. The less I slept, the less energy I had. The less energy I had, the more I ate to compensate. The more I ate, the more weight I put on.

I did enter a dilemma about not satisfying all my obligations and losing sleep over it. I gained weight again. Finally, I changed jobs and lost weight again. The 5-6 hours of sleep meant weight gain for me. The 8-9 hours meant weight loss was possible. 7 hours of sleep meant weight maintenance was possible with little effort.

Being mindful about sleeping more and eating right is the key. One myth I had to dispel taught by a popular self-help author is that happy people can survive on 5-6 hours of sleep and pursue their dreams and become extraordinary. The truth is be extraordinarily fat! 

READ MORE •••

Is Overuse of Antibiotics Causing an Explosion of Allergies and Asthma?

And this is why people are taking probiotics. We've super sanitized our homes and kids to the point they're essentially exposed to nothing, and thus have difficulty processing certain foods and have limited or problematic immune responses. Combine this with a continual decline in proper breastfeeding due to societal and employment pressures and the kids are not even betting a good start with a full suite of antibodies. READ MORE •••

Red Meat:  How Much is Too Much?

Here's a novel idea - eat in moderation and add some physical activity! Don't eat the the 3 lb. lard burger with all the trimmings, fries and wash it down with a 48 oz. cola then go sit on your fat a.. and wonder why I weigh 400 lbs. and need all the pharma drugs to keep me alive. I agree with the notion that processed red meat is bad but another killer to consider is most food that comes boxed/baged is highly processed with many preservatives.

READ MORE •••


ENVIRONMENT/NATURE

Beware Sly Santino and His Hidden Rock Pile

 

I'm wondering why no one is characterizing this as Santino actually using surprise tactics to engage an opponent.

I also love the phrase "whether some humanlike animal behaviors might have simpler explanations". It should be contrasted with "whether seemingly complex behaviors by humans are better explained as simple animal behavior". Just because we can come up with complex scenarios as to why we do certain things doesn't mean that is really why we are doing them.

READ MORE •••

 

Are Pit Bulls "Inherently Dangerous?"

As a dog owner, I think that all the attention placed on "pit bulls" (as if they are an entirely different species of animal from other dogs) is bad policy. In reality, all dogs can bite and larger dogs can usually inflict more harm than smaller dogs (the size/health of victim plays a part as well).

Particularly since it is so hard to determine the "breed" of many mixes and other shelter dogs, singling out dogs that they think are "pit bulls" (not even a breed recognized by the AKC, by the way) is stupid. People should be responsible for the behavior of their dogs, but whether a dog is a pit bull/Am Staff or German Shepherd or Labrador is not a definitive judgment on the dog's behavior or personality.

READ MORE •••

Before the Big Melt: CO2 and the Last Ice Age

The breathable atmosphere on this planet is only approximately 8 km thick. If you could point your car straight up, it would only take 5 minutes to get there driving at 100 km/Hr. It would only take an hour to park your car in low Earth orbit. That ain't a heck of alot.


Yes the Earth has gone through thousands of these cycles over millennia precisely for the reason that it doesn't take a huge shift to alter the climate in our incredibly thin atmosphere.


One can argue cause and affect all you want but, it is incredibly naive to think man's activities cannot affect something so susceptible to slight variations.


We will continue arguing until it is too late though as most cannot see the long term benefit of sustainable energy and our economic system will not allow it to fully develope at this point in time regardless. Unfortunately it always takes a war to mobilize man's true potential on a global scale.


No worry though...All will be affected soon enough. It is already starting to affect millions around the world. It's only a matter of time.

READ MORE •••

 

The Scientists, The Rat, and The Big Stick Insect

This is absolutely amazing. I've always loved bugs, stick bugs in particular. I'm just curious about eradicating ALL the rats on the island, would that have any impact on the ecosystem? I mean, yes rats are what most people consider a nuisance and disgusting, but don't they help in some ways as well? Eating other bugs to keep their populatations down? They eat carrion, and other garbage as well that might be benneficial. What would the effects of removing all the rats be?

READ MORE •••

 

 


BUSINESS

To Like or Not To Like Facebook IPO?

 

Mark Zuckerberg

  Guillaume Paumier/Wikipedia

Those who expect FB to be overtaken by something newer or better are wrong. 10% of all the people on earth have accounts. In contrast, nobody uses new services because nobody uses them. It's called the Network Effect, and it's nearly impossible to overcome. Just ask Google Plus: It's superior to Facebook in many ways, but it's a desert.

Comparisons to Myspace, Friendster, etc. are not useful. Those sites never achieved the critical mass of users to make them impregnable.

That said, though FB will outlive many of us, there's no guaranty that it will be profitable and therefore whether it will be a good stock to own. The new pricing and size of the IPO is a sign that the insiders aren't planning to give away anything. It may be a good buy at the new price, but it's not a steal.

Invest a small portion of your assets if you like to play, but don't be like that guy in an earlier WSJ story who's putting all his daughter's college savings into FB stock. That's just asking for an unhappy ending.

READ MORE •••

 

JP Morgan's $2 Billion Loss: " "Errors, sloppiness and bad judgment"

 

"Throughout the debate around the Volcker Rule, which is named after Paul A. Volcker, the former Federal Reserve chairman, Mr. Dimon has said the rule goes too far. Mr. Dimon told CNBC earlier this year that under the Volcker Rule, “if you want to be trading, you have to have a lawyer and a psychiatrist sitting next to you determining what was your intent every time you did something.”"

Hmmm.. How about a retiree, whose savings you are blowing, and a Chase teller, who earns 1000 times less than you, instead Jamie?

READ MORE •••

 

"Not Fit to Exercise Stewardship of Major Company," say British Lawmakers

Rupert Murcdoch  Photo: David Shankbone

I used to work for News Corp and met Mr Murdoch in passing a few times. He seemed like a pleasant person, however the way he has his supposed news companies run is utter garbage. It's a shame that a publication as prestigious as the Wall Street Journal is caught up in all of this mess. Say what you will about the "liberal media," at least they make sure they get the facts straight and always run corrections when they do not. He may be sorry, he may have even not been told specifics of what was happening, however he put in place a corporate atmosphere that brewed those results and deserves whatever he gets for it. 

READ MORE •••

A Dark Day for the Future of Books?

The theory here is that customers should embrace higher prices, since that will allow old-school, inefficient book publishers to stay in business rather than change their business practices and become more efficient in this new digital age.


Amazon is an aggressive, uncompromising competitor, yes. But unlike Apple and the five book publishers that are now being sued, and fairly so, by the DOJ, Amazon has not broken any laws. In fact, Amazon can and should be credited with jumpstarting the eBook industry, which was a backwater wasteland before the company released its Kindle platform.


While Amazon was busy building a business everyone else thought was superfluous, even industry seer CEO Steve Jobs said the Kindle would fail.

READ MORE •••


 


PEOPLE

 

Remembering Writer Carlos Fuentes, a Universal Mexican

What a brilliant Renaissance man, virtuoso writer, inspiring and kind teacher.

His sweeping vision encompassing both cyclic and linear time inspired me as no other; his novel "The Death of Artemio Cruz" a precision-wrought jewel perfectly merging form and content, Citizen Kane and Faulkner fused in a top-to-bottom x-ray of Mexican society and history in the first half of the twentieth century, lit by lights cosmic and visceral; his love of Proust, Tristram Shandy, and Cervantes; of language; of women in all their forms from Aura to Malinche to the wizened crones who have seen and known life's circus from inside out, who have lived to bear fruit and watch its corrupting cycles of decay (were these perhaps inspired by his grandmothers, the ones whom he called "the two authors of my books, really"?).

He was generous, supportive, a force of nature, vital source (as his name connotes), a gift to us all. I salute you, Fuentes, my one-time friend and mentor and perpetual inspiration! And my sympathy to Silvia, who knew him as no other 

READ MORE •••

 

"Sailing Home" - Remembering Maurice Sendak and the Wild Things

 

What a tribute to humankind, this man was. He put expression before perfection. He showed little people that their raucous energy and imaginative dark sides weren't strange or wrong. I'm honored and grateful to have lived when his work was fresh. I understand it was a challenge to some teachers and parents at the time. They were used to the anodyne product that kids were supposed to be seeing all the time. His work just cut through the clutter of all that. It demanded to be seen. I remember seeing it the first time and making the teacher let us see the book again and again. There was nothing like it, you could go into that world and be there for a while. A great example. A contrast to this packaged auto-tuned time.

READ MORE •••

The Perplexing Case of Activist Chen Guangcheng

Under international law, Mr. Guangchang would certainly be treated as a refugee were he to arrive at the United States' borders, since he clearly has a legitimate fear of political persecution. The situation is more difficult when he arrives, not at a United States border, but at the US embassy in Beijing. There is something called the 'diplomatic asylum' in international law, which seems to be basically what Mr. Guangchang sought. This occurs when a person appears, not at the borders of another country, but at that country's embassy, and seeks asylum. Under such circumstances, the general rule is that the receiving state cannot grant asylum to the person if the state where the embassy is located requests his surrender. The justification is that, in the absence of such rules, states might actually attack a foreign country's embassy, thus harming the stability of international relations.

All that said, I do think that the US should grant a visa to Mr. Guanchang, and let it be known by China and the rest of the world that it would like China to allow him to leave the country to get asylum in America. China may howl that this represents an 'interference' in its 'internal affairs'. But it is not as though US will send an army to secure Mr. Gunangchang's release; it would merely be applying moral pressure to compel China to release him. Nothing in international law protects China from being publicly embarrassed and revealed as the repressive, totalitarian regime that is is.

READ MORE •••


ENTERTAINMENT/SPORTS

Heartfelt Tributes to Donna Summer, Queen of Disco

My mom bought Love to Love You Baby on 8-Track. She loved Donna Summer the way I would grow to love Rush. She even cut and styled her dark hair to look the very style Donna is wearing in that iconic photo featured here. She and I would cruise the streets of El Paso in 1975-76 blasting the stereo of her boyfriend's 1974 Grand Prix in a time when it was still taboo for a woman to: divorce (oh, shame!), have a live-in boyfriend (scandal!), and embrace her sexuality (eternal damnation!). Looking back, I now see what Donna Summer embodied for my mother and millions of women coming of age in those duplicitous years.

READ MORE •••

Howard's Got Talent!

I'm a Stern admirer more than a fan; his schtick just isn't my cup of tea. However, his remarkable success at finding a unique (and lucrative) niche in our pop culture is worthy of the kudos of even the most priggish aesthete. His debut last night was a smash. Even in his prime on American Idol, Simon Cowell didn't rivet attention and set the tone as did Stern. His touch was masterful, sensitive, and often HILARIOUS! To my taste, he was edgy without really crossing any real "family time" boundaries and, although he grabbed the lion's share of the camera's focus, did not seem intrusive. NBC's "daring experiment" is off to a great start!  READ MORE •••

 

The Scream Brings a Shattering $119.9 Million at Auction

This is ridiculous: why are people disparaging wealth and personal choice? If any of us had that kind of pocket jingle to spend on a painting that we wanted, why shouldn't we buy it? So many of us dream of winning the lottery and landing hundreds of millions of dollars. Were any of us to win said lottery, or have our start-up company bought for a gazillion dollars by Microsoft or Facebook, to whom would we pay any attention, when we buy a nice car or a nicer home or a pricey painting, that we should be giving our earned or won money to the oppressed or underprivileged? We don't know the philanthropic inclinations of the painting's buyer and so -- whom are we to judge? The buyer is probably way psyched he or she won the auction, and let us celebrate that art still matters to some people, whether or not the sky's the limit.

READ MORE •••

The Avengers Launch Summer Movie Season with a Blast

I saw it yesterday in 3D, here in Germany it's running already. The performances are absolutely stunning, the new Hulk is the bomb. Fantastic storyline that really feels like a comic. Epic action scenes. Really, really epic. Great jokes. Did I say the action scenes are absolutely nuts? Yes. They're amazing. Also, character development, but not too much, not too little. Everything is just... right. It's unbelievable.

There is nothing really wrong with this movie. Almost 24 hours have passed and I'm still thinking about how great it was. That didn't happen to me since Kill Bill Vol. 1. I have to see it again, in the English original version the next time. Joss Whedon is more than a hero. He gave us Firefly, and now he gave us The Avengers. Thank you so much, Joss Whedon. I pray that you'll direct the sequel as well 

READ MORE •••


 

About Commentopia

A Digest of Best Readers' Comments curated from top news sites and blogs. READ MORE

Support Commentopia

 

 

Thank You for Your Support

 

Commentopia is an Amazon Affiliate site. If you click on a link to Amazon and buy an item there, a small portion of your purchase will go to supporting the curation of Commentopia.


 

@commentopia

Bookmark and Share

 

submit to reddit

Bloggers - Meet Millions of Bloggers

CONTACT

COMMENTOPIA

©2009-2012 COMMENTOPIA

 

 

advertisement

Riding the Rails: Teenagers on the Move During the Great Depression is a riveting document of hope and hardship during one of this nation's bleakest eras.

Uys so thoroughly recreates the wretched conditions the boxcar boys and girls endured that the reader can all but hear the cadence of the trains on the tracks and the lonesome wail at every whistle stop. -- Boston Globe

An elegantly presented and quietly moving collection of firsthand reminiscences, capturing a unique moment in American history. Enthusiastically recommended.

-- Library Journal

One of the most poignant memories of the wandering youth of the Great Depression

-- Sacramento Bee

PRINT &  E-BOOK

 

COMMENTOPIA

Curating the Best Comments from Top News Sites and Blogs