commentopia

The Digest of Best Readers' Comments

 

WORLD

September 2011

 

 

HOME   WORLD   NATIONAL   BUSINESS   SCI/TECH   HEALTH/EDUCATION   SPORTS/ENTERTAINMENT  PEOPLE  ENVIRONMENT

 

 

A Questioning Generation Takes to the Streets in Scorn and Anger

Wall Street, NY,  Athens, Greece; Madrid, Spain - Protests 2010-2011 via Wikipedia

 

I personally have heard the teaching of "free everything" at Harvard and when I asked if the electricity was free was essentially drowned out of the conversation. The person stating "free everything" had obviously been born into wealth and power in a foreign country, benefited from a world class education but had not been taught the fundamentals of economics. Instead he(yes it was a man) had learned to parrot his social group, perhaps to retain social standing?

It concerned me then and concerns me now. Why can we collectively not develop new economic models and a legitimate distribution of wealth? The 40 hour work week is arbitrary, prices can for too often now have no relation to cost of good produced and the increasing concentration of wealth globally echoes the court of Louis XVI prior to the French Revolution.

Worldwide that type of turmoil is unnecessary but it is possible if the extremely wealthy do not pay attention, quickly build in new and creative change and be willing to actually work for their livings. Will their financial managers even let the message reach them? Self-interest predicts they will not. The same is true for the security interests. Some threats may indeed be real and do need attention but repeating past thinking in the day of bio, telecom and nuclear risks is inappropriate and high risk for us all.

Democracy, real democracy is the only way to build justice and consensus into our world. As long as we are breathing there is hope.

Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/ As Scorn for Vote Grows, Protests Surge Around Globe

<>

Democracy is looking more and more like a sham, but what's the alternative? The last time democracy was so utterly rejected and scorned by so many people was in the 1920's, and that led to the twin totalitarian evils of communism and fascism.

I gotta admit, I have been greatly encouraged by all the global movements for justice, for "Real Democracy" (the name of the Spanish movement this spring), for "Social Justice" (as the Israels chanted), and all the rest. But the level of cynicism is may be too much of a good thing, of course we shouldn't blindly trust our leaders, but if we denigrate all and any potential political leaders, we end up powerless, with a strangely "apolitical political movement." And what do we gain? Nothing.

Here in Chile, a popular slogan of the 5-month long student protest movement has been "El pueblo unido avance sin partido" or "The people united go forward without a (political) party." But how? A poll out today shows that the student demands have a whopping 89% approval. So how on earth can't a democratic system not respond to that?

Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/ As Scorn for Vote Grows, Protests Surge Around Globe

Wall Street Protests September 2011 Photo by David Shankbone via Wikipedia

 

What has coincided with the spread of this disillusionment? The spread of neoliberal policies, that, in effect, place the wealthy and large, international corporations in charge, worldwide.

No state can effectively contest them. Indeed, governments, while nominally democratic, become captives of finance. (See the writings of Simon Johnson, former chief economist of the IMF.) Globalization, with no boundaries related to environmental or labor regulation, frees capital from ability of nation states to control it. If corporations don't like a state's policies, whether regulation of capital or the environment or labor laws protecting workers, financiers threaten to leave and take their capital with them.

400 families in the US now control as much wealth as the bottom 40-50 percent of US citizens. One billionaire in Mexico possesses as much wealth as 150 million Mexicans. The same pattern increasingly applies worldwide. Thus the similarity of the complaints of citizens worldwide.

Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/ As Scorn for Vote Grows, Protests Surge Around Globe

<>

I was there for the civil rights movement. I was there for the anti-war movement. I was there for the women's march on the Pentagon...and then for two decades I got co-opted into believing the system was actually gonna work for me.

Now, I'm almost sixty, unemployed for three years with a husband who just lost his job through an e-mail. Our health insurance is $800 a month, and he gets $160 a week in unemployment.

Well guess what we've got? Time. I stand in solidarity with those on Wall Street and am ashamed that it took this long to bring me back to the essential truth of what this country is about. Unbridled corporate greed.

Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/ As Scorn for Vote Grows, Protests Surge Around Globe

<>

Young voters helped bring President Obama into office, Hoping for Change. No wonder they are disillusioned. The massive TARP bailout did nothing to re-open local stores. Stimulus spending didn’t reach friends who now scramble to pay off college loans or find a minimum wage job.

They watched as Wall Street bankers were awarded huge bonuses, yet no one is prosecuted for stealing their future. Foreclosure signs continue to go up in their neighborhoods and even after passage of the “Affordable Care Act”. When you are unemployed, who can afford a $5,000 deductible? The Fed, Congress, and the White House flap around.

As 25 year-olds with college degrees deliver pizza, they hear about Bernie Madoff, the Koch Brothers, Citizens United, Solyndra, and new laws requiring voter ID cards. Boots dusty from Afghanistan return home to empty manufacturing plants. Why are we surprised when young voters feel pushed aside in a society controlled by privilege and wealth?

This is not the first time young voters have felt this way. In 1932 thousands of the disenfranchised and unemployed veterans demonstrated outside the White House. It required soldiers with fixed bayonets and live ammunition to push them away. As Intel co-founder Andy Grove says, “unemployment is corrosive”.

Either WE come together to restructure the American economy for the benefit of us all, or these young voters will bring it to our attention – in ways the rest of America may not like.

Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/ As Scorn for Vote Grows, Protests Surge Around Globe

 

Palestine: On  the Eve of the U.N. Vote

Gaza City Skyline via Wikipedia

The Palestinians have a right to petition the U.N. for recognition, for membership and even for establishment of a territorial home, just as Israel achieved. The United States serves its heritage poorly in denying any people that peaceful avenue to achieving their interests. If we believe in the U.N. we should support its efforts to resolve territorial disputes peacefully; if we don't believe in supporting its efforts, we should remove ourselves and our money from an organization in which we have so little faith and whose credibility we so easily dismiss.

Read the article NPR/Palestinians To Seek Full U.N. Membership Next Week

<>

You should not mistake ghosts of the mind for actual events in the physical world. We never opted for this "siege mentality" nor do we want it, but caution and suspicion and anxiety are natural responses of the few surrounded by many that are hostile.

If we were many and if the enemy were few - the situation would be different. But rejecting real threats as paranoia is self-delusion. We never asked the "Palestinians" to terrorize us, steal our ancient homeland, steal and rewrite our 4000 years of Jewish history nor did we ask them to engage in boycotts, propaganda, terrorism, missile attacks, rocket attacks, kidnapping, demographic warfare nor acting the Trojan Horse of 22 anti-Semitic Arab states.

We never asked Turkey to provoke us. We never asked Turkey to breach our moral, just and legal blockade of Gaza - which by the way doesn't belong to any "Palestinian" people or state in the history of mankind - nor did we ask the Turks to beat up and manhandle our soldiers. Our soldiers acted bravely and responsibly and I'm very proud of them.

Change our policies? How about the "Palestinians" and the Turks changing their policies against us and getting off our backs?

Read the article  YNET NEWS/Israel's siege mentality

<>

As a Turkish-American in NY with many Jewish friends, colleagues, I have followed recent development closely. Frankly, I am concerned, and don't think any of this is headed in a good direction.

Talk of war is grandstanding - the reality is, Israel & Turkey, cannot and will not go to war. It disappoints me to see the yip-yap on some of these comments around who is stronger, etc. The bigger matter that will affect Israeli (and to a lesser degree, Turkish) day to day lives is commercial trade. Any lifting of normal trading relationships will affect both nations greatly, probably Israel a little more so. That is not to say that Turkey will not suffer - Israel is technologically far advanced to anyone else in the region, and this has benefited Turkey greatly.

The whole thing is disappointing - I used to carry the close Turko-Israeli relationship as a source of pride. I think it is important for Israelis and Jews worldwide to understand the history of Turkish/Jewish relationships throughout history. We have been your friends for centuries. Yes, the US is your largest backer right now, but that is a consequence of money influencing politicians. Absent this influence, don't go looking to the Anglo-Saxon world for friendship.

Read the article YNET NEWS/Warships can be in E-Med at any moment

<>

This is the result of a changing reality in the Middle East and the Arab tribes each fighting for a place of power and wealth in tomorrow's region.

Israel is just the punching bag, as usually.

Arab despots are trying to hold on to power and blame "Zionists" for issues in their countries.

Other leaders claim to be the new prophet and will lead Arab Middle East to the new enlightened age.

All claim to be friends of the "Palestinians" yet treat those hosted in their respective countries like crap.

Now Abdallah is rattling his sword against Israel. Why? Not because he hates Israel but because he knows how fragile his kingdom is under the parasitic threat of "Palestinians".

All of this Arab rhetoric is common over the past 1400 years, and is not about Israel. It's about those trying to gain power and those trying to hold on to power.

Read the article YNET NEWS/Warships can be in E-Med at any moment

<>

Turkey has been Israel's best friend in the region for years. Turkey is not an enemy of Israel...only the conduct of Israel could make it one. Israel no longer has a firm grasp on Gaza's southern border... the blockade of Gaza can't do what Israel claims it is intended for. All it can do is continue to stifle any economic growth, any chance to achieve self-sufficiency...ironically, any positive alternative to violent resistance.

It is past time for Israel to end the siege, end the occupation of the West Bank, and make a serious effort at peace with the Palestinians... something it has never yet done. 

Read the article  DAILY BEAST/the Erdogan Doctrine

<>

You have just published the most outspoken and fair assessment of the Israeli Palestinian issue that I have ever seen in the mainstream Western media, which has always shielded Israel from serious criticism by simply downplaying or ignoring their unjust and illegal actions and positions in the past.

However, like the others, you have not pointed out the most obvious consequence of the U.S. policy of overly protecting and condoning Israel’s positions – terror attacks against the United States, however unjustified and cruel such acts are. Yes, 9/11 was such an act, but over the past ten years, no one in the mainstream media had made such a simple connection– 9/11 and other acts were just attacks by “terrorists” who carried them out simply
to “terrorize”.

Perhaps the American public should be made aware of this - not that their government should change policies to appease the terrorists but simply because it would be right and it
would reduce anti-U.S. feelings in the region and elsewhere thus reducing the support base of the terrorists. This
could be done without sacrificing the State of Israel but by asking them to make a few sacrifices – we would like to have everything on our wish list but we can’t.

Read the article TIME/Why the Obama Administration is Failing in its Efforts to Stop the Palestinians' U.N. Bid

 

<>

Let me point out another dynamic that seems to be unfolding. the peace process used to be a thing of the US, Israel and the PA along with Egypt and Jordan. The governments of the latter two countries simply went along with what ever was put on the table by the US, for own interest and against the wills of their citizens.

Now the rise of Turkey as a regional power coupled with the Arab spring have shuffled the actors. Unlike Egypt and Jordan, Turks , at least at the governmental level, are genuinely interested in pressing the Palestinian issue further into global diplomatic arena. they are creating a lot more pressure on PA government (and providing strategic advice and resources) than one could have expected from Jordanian and Egyptian governments.

If PA backs down, that will not only reflect poorly in the streets of Gaza, it will also be a major blow to the credibility and sincerity of Abbas in the eyes of Turkish government. Not to mention, a boost to the hand of Iran

Read the article TIME/Why the Obama Administration is Failing in its Efforts to Stop the Palestinians' U.N. Bid

 

Libyan Rebels on Final Drive Against Gadhafi Regime 

 

Tripoli August 21, 2o11 vua RT Russia Today

 

My eyes well up and my throat tightens with feeling for the Libyan rebels, who have persevered against great odds and with great courage, not knowing how to fight a war yet fighting nonetheless, and now on the verge of winning.

They have right and morality on their side. I hope that when they take control, they will be able to resist destructive urges such as tribalism, lust for power, using gunfire to settle disagreements, and failing to realize that, despite the issues that may divide them, they all have one overriding issue in common: desire for freedom.

It is this desire that has brought them this far, and in forming a government and a political system - things in which they have absolutely no experience, at the express commands of Qaddafi - they must remember that above all they are human beings who love freedom enough to die for it, and it is freedom that can unite them and show them how to govern themselves.

Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/ More Clashes After Rebels Sweep Tripoli

<>

The heroic Libyan people will soon defeat Qaddafi and his dictatorial regime. Salute to the people’s revolutionary cause in solidarity.

However, Libyan people’s democratic revolution is just beginning. Enormous difficulties and barriers are ahead. They should overcome these difficulties with continued revolutions without hesitation. No genuine people’s revolution can claim final victory after overthrowing the dictatorial regime. The reactionary regime and its lackeys will not give in easily. They want to serve the enemies of the people both at home and abroad to restore their lost paradise by counter-revolutionary activities, openly or covertly.

International monopoly capital will certainly want to buy off corrupted officials and traitors in Libya to take control and even sole ownership of petroleum and natural gas resources. Revolutionaries should fight against the colonialist forces and their schemes by continuing revolutions. They should not lay down their arms before they establish a genuine revolutionary regime and thoroughly destroy domestic and foreign counter-revolutionary forces in Libya. A nationwide cultural revolution is necessary to wipe out the remnants of the enemy’s ideology and the old culture.

Again, people’s revolution can never end.

Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/ More Clashes After Rebels Sweep Tripol

<>

To those praising President Obama and NATO for completing their objectives, let history being a warning to you. The same was said when the "Mission Accomplished" banner was unfurled behind GWB. The war is most certainly not over. The army of the Qaddafi regime is still out there and it is still very loyal. And what are we celebrating? Yes, a cruel regime is now in tatters but who knows what may come. Does 1979 Afghanistan ring a bell? Who did we support in this war? Are they really the purveyors of Democracy? Will we have to intervene again to prevent more bloodshed and persecution? Recent events in Egypt seem to confirm this.

I'm holding by judgement for now. The responsibilities of President Obama and NATO have not ended yet.

Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/ More Clashes After Rebels Sweep Tripol

Interesting the number of predictions about Libya becoming a terrorist state post-Gadaffi. First of all, Gadaffi created a true terrorist state in the first place, and only agreed to cooperate with GWB when he became concerned that he could be the next Saddam after 9/11 attacks.

Moreover, Mustafa Abdul Jalil is the clear leader of the rebel forces. He has a long record of opposition to the Gaddaffi regime, and has a very positive rating from Human Rights Watch.

It is too early to tell what may happen to the future of Libya. On the other hand it is rather silly for those around here to scoff, especially given that so many of the detractors are so blindly stupid when it comes to Libya in the first place. I guess the real fear on the right is that Obama may get some credit for helping the rebels overthrow Gaddaffi. And we wouldn't want that now, would we?

Read the article  WALL STREET JOURNAL/Tripoli Jubilant, Jittery Amid Pockets of Resistance

<>

The rebel's victory is a testament to a certain amount of advance planning and coordination with NATO which is anxious to terminate this prolonged conflict.

The rebels, to their credit, have come a long way from a disorganized protest movement to being a loosely organized group to overthrow a despotic ruler. But they're still largely a civilian force with virtually no military training.

The Libyan National Transitional Council is now charged with imposing order in a large city and they could start by sending UNIFORMED troups to Tripoli.

To heal the wounds of war something like a truth and reconciliation commission or military or civilian tribunals to prosecute crimes may be needed. The sooner that Seif al-Islam is tried and, if convicted, hanged (preferably in a public square) the better. The same goes for Gadhafi's other top henchmen and for Gadhafi himself if he is captured alive (and any other persons committing atrocities against civilians).

Prolonging trials of such individuals just serves to promote instability as was shown by the Iraqi experience with Saddam Hussein after his capture.

Read the article  WALL STREET JOURNAL/Tripoli Jubilant, Jittery Amid Pockets of Resistance

 

READ MORE TOP COMMENTS: JULY - AUGUST 2011


 

back to home page

About Commentopia

The Digest of Best Readers' Comments

Thousands of comments read and curated from top news sites and blogs for the most original, insightful and informative opinions on current topics... READ MORE

Support Commentopia

 

Thank You for Your Support

 

Commentopia is an Amazon Affiliate site. If you click on a link to Amazon and purchase an item there, a small portion of your purchase will go to supporting the curation of Commentopia.


 

@commentopia

Bookmark and Share

 

submit to reddit

 

CONTACT

COMMENTOPIA

©2009-2011 COMMENTOPIA

 

 

 

THE WIRES

AFP via YAHOO

AP WORLD
AP NATIONAL

AP NEWS VIDEO

BUSINESS NEWS WIRE

INDIA-ASIA NEWS

INTERFAX

INTERNET NEWS

ITAR-TASS RUSSIA

KYODO JAPAN

MCCLATCHY

MERCOPRESS

NASDAQ HEADLINES

N.Y. TIMES WIRE

REUTER'S

UPI

ZINHAU CHINA NEWS

 

THE WEB

ALLAFRICA

ARS TECHNICA

BOING-BOING

BREITBART

BUSINESS INSIDER

BUZZ FEED

BUZZ MACHINE  

CONSERVATIVE BLOG

DAILY BEAST

DAILY HOWLER
DAILY KOS
DAILY SWARM

DRUDGE REPORT

E! ONLINE

FREE REPUBLIC

GAWKER

GLOBAL POST

GOOGLE NEWS

HOT AIR

HUFFINGTON POST

IAFRICA

ISRAEL NEWS

LUCIANNE.COM

MOTLEY FOOL

MY WAY

NEWSLOOK
NEWSMAX

ONION

POLITICAL WIRE

POLITICO

PROPUBLICA

RADAR

REALCLEAR POLITICS

REUTER'S BLOGS

ROLL CALL

SALON

SEATTLE POST INTELLI.SLATE

SMOKING GUN
SPLASH NEWS

TALKING POINTS MEM

TECHCRUNCH

THE HILL

TMZ

TOPIX

WORLDNETDAILY

WOWOWOW

YAHOO NEWS

YOUTUBE


advertisement

A masterpiece! Brazil has the feel of an  enchanted virgin forest, a totally new and original world for the reader-explorer to discover.... Pulsing with vigor, this is a vast novel to tell the story of a vast country. Uys recreates history almost entirely "at ground level," through the eyes and actions of an awesome cast of characters. L'Express, Paris

Uys has accomplished what no Brazilian author from José de Alencar to Jorge Amado was able to do. He is the first to write our national epic in all its decisive episodes, from the indigenous civilization and the El Dorado myth, everything converging like the segments of a rose window to that reborn and metamorphosed myth that is Brasilia.

He is the first outsider to see us with total honesty and sympathy and full empathy with the decisive moments in our history and their spiritual meaning. Descriptions like those of the war with Paraguay are unsurpassed in our literature and evoke the great passages of War and Peace. Wilson Martins, Jornal do Brasil

PRINT & KINDLE


NEWSMAP

WORLD NEWSPAPERS ONLINE

WORLD FRONT PAGES

WEATHER CHANNEL

WORLD WEATHER FORECASTS

 

U.S.PRINT SOURCES

ARIZONA REPUBLIC

ATLANTA JOURNAL-CONST.

BALTIMORE SUN

BOSTON GLOBE
BOSTON HERALD

CHICAGO SUN-TIMES
CHICAGO TRIBUNE
CHRISTIAN SCIENCE-

MONITOR

CLEVELAND PLAIN- DEALER

DALLAS MORNING- NEWS

DENVER POST

DETROIT FREE PRESS

FINANCIAL TIMES
FORBES

FORTUNE

HOLLYWOOD REPORTER

HOUSTON CHRONICLE
INVESTORS BUSINESS DAILY

INDIANAPOLIS STAR

KANSAS CITY STAR
L0S ANGELES TIMES

MIAMI HERALD

MILWAUKEE JOURNAL- SENTINEL

MINNEAPOLIS STAR- TRIBUNE

NATION
NATIONAL ENQUIRER
NATIONAL REVIEW
NEW JERSEY STAR-LEDGER

NEW REPUBLIC

NEW YORK

NEW YORK DLY NEWS
NEW YORK OBSERVER
NEW YORK POST
NEW YORK TIMES
NEW YORKER
NEWSWEEK

OREGONIAN

ORANGE COUNTY- REGISTER

ORLANDO SENTINEL
PEOPLE
PHILADELPHIA- INQUIRER
PHILADELPHIA DAILY NEWS

PITTSBURGH POST-GAZETTE

REASON MAG
ROLLING STONE

SACRAMENTO BEE

SAN ANTONIO EXP- NEWS

SAN DIEGO UNION-TRIB
SAN FRANCISCO- CHRONICLE

SAN JOSE MERCURY- NEWS
STAR

ST. LOUIS POST- DISPATCH

ST.PETERSBURG- TIMES
TIME

U.S. NEWS
USA TODAY
VANITY FAIR
VARIETY

VILLAGE VOICE

WALL STREET JNL
WASHINGTON POST
WASHINGTON TIMES
WEEKLY STANDARD

WIRED

 

INTL. PRINT SOURCES

AUSTRALIAN

CANADA GLOBE & MAIL

CANADA NATL POST

DER SPIEGEL INTL.

INDIA TIMES

INTL. HERALD TRIBUNE

IRISH TIMES

JERUSALEM POST

JOHANNESBURG STAR

KENYA DAILY NATION

MOSCOW TIMES

PAKISTAN DAWN

PAKISTAN NEWS INTL.

PRAVDA

S.A. MAIL&GUARDIAN

S.AFRICA TIMES

SYDNEY MORNING HERALD

TORONTO STAR

TORONTO SUN
[U.K.] DAILY MAIL
[U.K.] DAILY MIRROR
[U.K.] DAILY RECORD

[U.K.] ECONOMIST
[U.K.] EVENING STANDARD
[U.K.] EXPRESS
[U.K.] GUARDIAN
[U.K.] INDEPENDENT
[U.K.] NEWS OF THE WORLD

[U.K.] NEW STATESMAN

[U.K.] SCOTSMAN

[U.K.] SPECTATOR
[U.K.] SUN
[U.K.] TELEGRAPH
[U.K.] TIMES

VANCOUVER SUN

 

RADIO AND TV

ABC NEWS

AL JAZEERA

BBC
BBC VIDEO & AUDIO

BBC WORLD SERVICE

BLOOMBERG

CBC NEWS
CBS NEWS

CITADEL- BROADCASTING

CLEAR CHANNEL- RADIO
C-SPAN
CNN

CNN VIDEO & AUDIO

DAILY SHOW

ESPN
EW ENTERTAINMENT- WEEKLY
FOXNEWS
MSNBC

NPR

PBS

SKY NEWS

 

CONTACT

COMMENTOPIA

©2090 - 2011 COMMENTOPIA

 


advertisement

Riding the Rails: Teenagers on the Move During the Great Depression is a riveting document of hope and  hardship during one of this nation's bleakest eras.

Uys so thoroughly recreates the  wretched conditions the boxcar boys and girls endured  that the reader can all but hear the cadence of the  trains on the tracks and the lonesome wail at every  whistle stop. Boston Globe

An elegantly presented and quietly moving collection of firsthand reminiscences, capturing a unique moment in American history. Enthusiastically recommended.

-- Library Journal

One of the most poignant memories of the wandering youth of the Great Depression

-- Sacramento Bee

 

PRINT & KINDLE


 

A SERVICE BRINGING YOU THE BEST READERS' COMMENTS FROM TOP NEWS SOURCES ON THE WEB