commentopia "The Big Story, The Best Comments"

  FRONT PAGE  WORLD  NATIONAL   BUSINESS   SCI/TECH   HEALTH/EDUCATION   SPORTS/ENTERTAINMENT   PEOPLE   ENVIRONMENT

 

SCI/TECH

January 2012

 

Wikipedia Blackout Protests SOPA

I'm down already, and will remain down for the duration of the emergency. I'm a little fish with only a few thousand monthly users. It's little enough but it's what I can do and I'm not giving this one whit less than all I've got.

What these people propose is to strip all citizens of their rights to freedom of speech and due process of law to protect the profitability of a 90 year old mouse cartoon. I am a huge fan of freedom of speech and if a simple citizen were to stand up and argue for that I would argue with him but I would defend his right to say his piece. And then I'll make fun of him for acting the fool.

For a representative of the people to propose or support a law to deprive the People of their inalienable rights to freely speak or have due process of law is a different thing. It's Serious Business. You don't get to take that back. There is no compromise position to be had here, no middle course. That is a failure of citizenship, a neglect of your civic duty - an admission that you _just don't understand_ that some things are not negotiable. These rights are the very rights our nation was founded to preserve. We went to war with England for just this. Once you've supported legislation to deprive the rights of citizens to freely speak or have due process of law you're a threat to the Republic and need to be removed from office as swiftly as the democratic process will allow. You just don't get a do-over on this one.

Cory's right. This is just evil

Read the article .BOING BOING/Boing Boing will go dark on Jan 18 to fight SOPA & PIPA

<>

Like most blogs that strive to pass on ANY amount of information while relaying the sources, mine would be crippled by SOPA, even if I moved it off the Google servers. And if it were blacklisted in the US, all those good friends I started writing it for wouldn't be able to read it.

I mean, just yesterday, I wrote about how I was born into a country with no free speech, and how incredibly grateful I was that it was restored while I was still a child. Thank you, I don't want another Iron Curtain.

Read the article .BOING BOING/Boing Boing will go dark on Jan 18 to fight SOPA & PIPA

<>

Cory, I understand the depth of feelings you have on this issue, but punishing your visitors is not the way to achieve legislative success. The White House has taken a stand against these bills, and more and more in Congress are realizing the downstream consequences. Congress is working on the bills, and it's highly unlikely that *really* bad legislation will make it through both Houses and the White House.

I for one do not plan to punish my vistors, and I'll think long and hard about any web site that chooses to punish their visitors. I just recently got a kudo from Reddit for being there six years. I'm not all that active there, and I personally don't see that I have anything to lose by deleting my account. If they indeed "go dark", I'll probably delete my account when they come back up.

I think you should re-consider, but I'll understand if you do "go dark."

Read the article .BOING BOING/Boing Boing will go dark on Jan 18 to fight SOPA & PIPA

<>

Respectfully, I don't see it at all as 'punishing' one's visitors. I would like to think that visitors of a site (especially a free blog like BB) have a bit more of a relationship with their hosts. To describe their decision to dedicate the site to an issue like SOPA, for a mere 12 hours, as 'punishment' makes it sound like average visitors are children who expect nothing but free candy in the most immediate way at all times.

I, for one, have been reading Boing Boing for several years now and I certainly don't mind them taking a few hours out of their 'regular programming' to make a point about something they feel is important.

I have been away from my computer, and BB, for at least 12 hours at a time... I don't feel it's too much to ask of their readers to stand by and share a thought about something they feel strongly about for a short time. Then it's right back to free candy!!

Read the article .BOING BOING/Boing Boing will go dark on Jan 18 to fight SOPA & PIPA

<>

Web sites such as yours consistently make it seem that the only entities hurt by internet theft are large corporations. This is not true. I am a small independent publisher making ends meet with a meager income from a book I wrote. I notify sites of copyright infringement per the DCMA, it takes days to remove the link and, if it's removed at all, more links pop up within days. Internet theft takes food off my table and presents from under my tree. Internet theft hurts people, not just corporations, and it stifles creativity. Why spend years writing a book when it can be stolen and distributed in minutes? Why rent studio time to produce a song when you know you will never make that money back because people are stealing your hard work because sites such as yours make it easy to do while throwing up their electronic hands and screaming, "it's not my fault! I just host the thieves!"

Read the article .BOING BOING/Boing Boing will go dark on Jan 18 to fight SOPA & PIPA

<>

Dear Wikipedia,

We know we've had our differences in the past. Your community is often less than inclusive and your articles--to be perfectly blunt--aren't always as neutral as you would have us believe. Your definitions of relevant sources is, honestly, too narrow and your reactions towards infractions can often be too severe (or not severe enough).

We know you have your own beefs with us, too. We rather like the fact that all your content costs only the mild hindrance that your fundraising banners cause to our browser real-estate, and we know you really, really, really would like some money from us. We know our love of anonymity, pranks, and non-stop bickerings can cause you headaches and legal troubles.

But now that you've jumped on our bandwagon of anti-SOPA/PIPA support, let's let bygones be bygones. We always knew that our cause was your cause, but to see you throw your support so wholly behind us when so many of our other previous darlings have lost their way? It practically brings tears to our monocled eyes! We our ever so thankful for your show of support, maybe even enough to steer some funds into those donation banners (or maybe not quite that grateful).

Yours sincerely,
The Internet

P.S. We apologize in advance for all future page defacing we will continue to commit. We just can't help ourselves. But it's out of love, honest!

Read the article ARS TECHNICA/Wikipedia to join reddit in SOPA blackout Wednesday

<>

The Stop Online Piracy Act in the U.S. House of Representatives and the Protect Intellectual Property Act under consideration in the Senate are designed to crack down on sales of pirated U.S. products overseas.

Look, I'm all for protections for IP but this wouldn't solve the problem. Instead, it invites lawsuits, confusion, and bizarre unilateral new rules for the Internet.

Read the article WALL STREET JOURNAL/Wikipedia to Go Dark Over Antipiracy Bill

<>

Did anyone take the time to read the SOPA in its entirety?

SOPA attaches civil and/or criminal liability to the following actions:

1) Discussing copyright infringement whether directly or tangentially. Includes academic journals, white papers, corporate memos, casual online discussions between friends, online discussion forums, etc.

2) Writing and distributing source code of software that may be used for copyright infringement.

3) Writing a manual on how to infringe on copyrights.

4) Conducting online or physical classes on how to infringe on copyrights or that may lead to the infringement of copyrights. Includes academic classes, professional classes, online classes by academic institutions, and classes conducted by hackers/pirates.

5) Showing someone how to infringe on copyrights. Includes academic journals, white papers, comments by hackers, newspaper articles, etc.

6) Posting links to websites that shows someone how to infringe on copyrights

7) Posting links to source codes of software that may be used for copyright infringement

8) Posting links to downloadable files of software that may be used for copyright infringement

9) Reverse engineering software and hardware that are intended to prevent copyright infringement

10) Building or installing hardware that are designed to infringe on copyrights, even if hardware is not distributed or sold to anyone. This includes modchips to Wii, Xbox, Playstation, etc. Also includes hardware hacks or modifications to your car's electronics systems.

The list simply goes on and on. ANYTHING that can or may be used to DIRECTLY infringe on copyrights or CONTRIBUTING in any way or form to copyright infringement (whether through online speech, source code of programs, posting of links, or even casual online discussion) WILL be subject to civil and/or criminal liability under the SOPA.

This is NOT an exaggeration. This is the way the SOPA is designed today. Don't believe me or want to argue my points? READ the SOPA.

Read the article WALL STREET JOURNAL/Wikipedia to Go Dark Over Antipiracy Bill

<>

The point here is onus and order of suit operations.

Currently, you cannot sue a middleman for putting through information that a primary dealer stole from someone else.

Those middlemen make you sign agreements before you can use their sites which requires you (the poster or dealer) to certify and own your actions.

Since the industry is having trouble making money by suing the end user (snall pockets, many suits), they want the right to sue the middleman (single suit, large pockets).

Are they right, no. Would they win those suits against the middlemen, no. So, they don't want to even have to go to court to assert their rights. They want to be able to call their local friendly politician and get them to take the site down with no jurisprudence.

That is about as anti-freedom as you can get.

Politicians in the senate and house are licking their lips for this free for all smorgasbord of bribes and "contributions" to get them to take down nasty sites who can't be beaten in a lawsuit.

The fact that Wiki is a not-for-profit, makes these folks go nuts, because wiki is asserting that the information on their site is "general knowledge" and therefore free from intellectual property infringement.

In the end, not being able to effectively sue or defend yourself in court is usually a problem for the little guy (me and you) not for a big corporation (so they are pissed).

How about a deal, we get a law that bans BMA (binding mandatory arbitration) and in return we create a class suit for corporations against large groups of offenders in piracy that meet certain requirements (so as not to be a catch all for anyone they want to sue).

Thoughts?

Read the article WALL STREET JOURNAL/Wikipedia to Go Dark Over Antipiracy Bill

<>

This comment has been removed by federal authorities for having unknown links to allegedly blacklisted material.

Read the article NPR/In Protest Of Anti-Piracy Bill, Wikipedia To Go Dark

The creepiest thing about this entire thing is when you consider how many US "Entertainment" companies own the major ISPs. Think Time/Warner (Roadrunner cable in the Southwest/Texas), Comcast (Comcast in the West, Charter and others in Central/Eastern states). Their having any kind of precedent to "thumb through" the content that you and I view, access or send across the net they would be given a green light to act like more than monopolies and become downright modern day Stasi, acting as an extention of the Federal Government by proxy on behalf of any of their "holdings" and/or "partners". THAT is creepy. And some out there believes that giving John Boehner and the GOP the chance to "do what's right" on behalf of intellectual property rights? Yeah, you can guess who they are and just how downright creepy they want to be. I fully support Wikipedia on this one. Jimmy Wales wouldn't be doing this if there was just a "possibility" that it could be used for major creepiness.

Read the article NPR/In Protest Of Anti-Piracy Bill, Wikipedia To Go Dark

<>

I disagree with Wikipedia on this one.

Music and films ARE products! They're not necessarily tangible products like tools or home appliances, but they are products that serve a purpose - to entertain the end user.

If you have a physical product that is patented, but someone else steals your idea, remakes the product, and sells it somewhere else, you would not be psyched. Well, that's exactly what happens with music and films. Those products have copyright protection. And people put in the time, energy, and know-how to make the product. So why shouldn't they make sure someone else isn't stealing it to make their own profit?

Stealing someone else's work and selling it for profit is NOT a form of free speech.

Read the article NPR/In Protest Of Anti-Piracy Bill, Wikipedia To Go Dark

CENTER STAGE AT CES 2012

Microsoft CES Keynote host Ryan Seacrest checks out Steve Ballmer's Windows Phone at CES 2012.  Image: Courtesy of Microsoft

Seems like a greatest hits keynote to me, recycling alot of old marketing taglines from the past with Bing, WP7, Windows 8 and I bet I am missing a few more of them too. But overall there is nothing worse than giving a keynote when you have nothing to say and MS has shown that tonight. Along with more contradictory behavior from MS, if they want their products to be seen as magical and classy, then they shouldn't resort to gimmicks like Ryan Seacrest, autotuned highlights, and the tweet choir.

MS re-relaunched Windows Mobile/Phone again. Unfortunately they are still pushing the same ideals that haven't been working and the Nokia phones while better than the entire lineup of Windows Phones, weren't that exciting. It didn't make me regret getting a Galaxy Nexus last month.

With Windows 8 I am surprised MS is sticking to the no compromises line when it is not true. I feel it is a bit misleading and will end up turning more people off. With Windows 8 being a big change from previous versions of windows, so you will have to compromise and learn to love it or hate it.

Read the article ARS TECHNICA/2012 CES Microsoft keynote liveblog

<>

This article seems a little biased. Microsoft has done plenty of innovation in the last decade. XBOX has taken off as one of the lead platforms, Windows 7 is a great OS and Windows Phone 7-though no where near Android's market-share- is doing well. Also, Office 2010 is well designed sweet. All in all, Microsoft has a lot more competition now and has lost some of it's staple products like IE to some of the competitors. Also, they haven't made an OS so far ahead of XP that big business is wiling to switch. Make no mistake, they are still innovative, just not at the rate of Apple of Google, who have had a great decade. The author is writing like they are irrelevant now. That is not the case. They are still dominant, and may have a shot reclaiming support with Windows 8. We'll see. 

Read the article  WIRED/With CES Sendoff, Microsoft Insists It’s Still Cool

 

<>

The phone and the consumer pc will be converging as phone hardware gets powerful enough to support desktop operating systems as well as the slimmed down mobile operating systems. The majority of consumer desktops/laptops will be replaced with docking stations that will allow a user to purchase one piece of hardware for their phone/pc/laptop (the atrix phone was on to something, but lacks the desktop os). Although they haven't mentioned the potential, it really sounds like Microsoft's Windows 8 is aimed directly at such a device. If the market heads this way, Apple and Google could be playing catch up.

Read the article  WIRED/With CES Sendoff, Microsoft Insists It’s Still Cool

 

<>

Why "go out with a bang" from a conference that you're not going to be supporting anymore? Most trade shows aren't worth going to anymore and I'm betting that the only reason Microsoft bothered to show up this year was because the probably pre-paid their reservation last year or the year before. Why debut their latest innovations in a forum where they're competing with countless other companies, and risk being overshadowed by one (or many) of their products? By hosting their own events and product roll-outs they don't have to worry about pressure to show "something big" at these shows, even if it's not ready, and face scrutiny if they run into issues that delay its release.

Read the article  WIRED/With CES Sendoff, Microsoft Insists It’s Still Cool

<>

I own a desktop and a laptop, but I also disagree that desktops aren't dying yet, cause it's easier to swap and upgrade components with a desktop than a laptop.. And I completely agree with ghost on the problem of overheating, since laptops tend to have it's components tightly squeezed together to make it 'thinner' and it's also doubly hard and more expensive to find upgrades for laptops making it too much of a hassle than a desktop.

Laptops are only great for presentations or when you're traveling because of it's portability. But most work involving computers allows people to stay on stable environments making the easily upgradeable desktops more viable.

Read the article   POPSCi/ What, Exactly, Is an Ultrabook?

 

 

Sweden Recognizes Church of Kopimisim -- A Religion of Copying and Pasting

CHURCH OF KOPIMISM/Image courtesy of Death and Taxes

 

"And the Lord said "Let there be data!" and the data did flow unceasingly unto the Holy Internet and to the faithful across the World Wide Web." You shall know the TRUTH (the computer) and the TRUTH will set your mind free.


Freedom of the MIND is neither political nor economic. Count me in. Or rather, paste me in.Copy that!Clever, you cut and pasted the last line of the article and changed a letter.ABBA, Volvo, and now this...gotta love those Swedes!And he said "Let there be CTRL+V"If you think you've created something truthful, it would be unethical to refuse to share it or demand payment for it, especially if its duplication doesn't diminish the original.

Read the article LOS ANGELES TIMES/Copying and file sharing recognized as a religion in Sweden

<>

All the big religions survived due to piracy. Monks didn't get approval of the copyright holders or their heirs to make copies of the various holy books. Without piracy, all of them would have been lost.

For that matter, all the classics survived due to piracy as well. Not only did people copy Euclid's Elements without permission but Euclid himself compiled it from earlier works.

The free exchange of information is the very basis of advancing civilization.

Without it, we would be a stone age monarchy but of course, that's the goal for some groups.

Read the article TORRENT FREAK/File-Sharing Recognized as Official Religion in Sweden

<>

However, as usual, the church, once established when it found it's monopoly on interpretating scripture threatened was the first organization to come out in massive condemnation of the printing press.

The core root of copyright is information control. It's never worked in practice but any vested interest keeps trying.

The scary part is that a paradigm was briefly established where people started taking it for granted that person A should be prohibited from copying information and give to person B. And this nonsense is what we're fighting.

Read the article TORRENT FREAK/File-Sharing Recognized as Official Religion in Sweden

 

READ MORE TOP COMMENTS: November - December 2011

 

 

back to home page

THE WIRES

AFP via YAHOO

AP WORLD
AP NATIONAL

AP NEWS VIDEO

BUSINESS NEWS WIRE

INDIA-ASIA NEWS

INTERFAX

INTERNET NEWS

ITAR-TASS RUSSIA

KYODO JAPAN

MCCLATCHY

MERCOPRESS

NASDAQ HEADLINES

N.Y. TIMES WIRE

REUTER'S

UPI

ZINHAU CHINA NEWS

 

THE WEB

ALLAFRICA

ARS TECHNICA

BOING-BOING

BREITBART

BUSINESS INSIDER

BUZZ FEED

BUZZ MACHINE  

CONSERVATIVE BLOG

DAILY BEAST

DAILY HOWLER
DAILY KOS
DAILY SWARM

DRUDGE REPORT

E! ONLINE

FREE REPUBLIC

GAWKER

GLOBAL POST

GOOGLE NEWS

HOT AIR

HUFFINGTON POST

IAFRICA

ISRAEL NEWS

LUCIANNE.COM

MOTLEY FOOL

MY WAY

NEWSLOOK
NEWSMAX

ONION

POLITICAL WIRE

POLITICO

PROPUBLICA

RADAR

REALCLEAR POLITICS

REUTER'S BLOGS

ROLL CALL

SALON

SEATTLE POST INTELLI.SLATE

SMOKING GUN
SPLASH NEWS

TALKING POINTS MEM

TECHCRUNCH

THE HILL

TMZ

TOPIX

WORLDNETDAILY

WOWOWOW

YAHOO NEWS

YOUTUBE


advertisement

Uys has accomplished what no Brazilian author from José de Alencar to Jorge Amado was able to do. He is the first to write our national epic in all its decisive episodes, from the indigenous civilization and the El Dorado myth, everything converging like the segments of a rose window to that reborn and metamorphosed myth that is Brasilia.

He is the first outsider to see us with total honesty and sympathy and full empathy with the decisive moments in our history and their spiritual meaning. Descriptions like those of the war with Paraguay are unsurpassed in our literature and evoke the great passages of War and Peace.

-- Wilson Martins Jornal do Brasil

 


NEWSMAP

WORLD NEWSPAPERS ONLINE

WORLD FRONT PAGES

WEATHER CHANNEL

WORLD WEATHER FORECASTS

 

U.S.PRINT SOURCES

ARIZONA REPUBLIC

ATLANTA JOURNAL-CONST.

BALTIMORE SUN

BOSTON GLOBE
BOSTON HERALD

CHICAGO SUN-TIMES
CHICAGO TRIBUNE
CHRISTIAN SCIENCE-

MONITOR

CLEVELAND PLAIN- DEALER

DALLAS MORNING- NEWS

DENVER POST

DETROIT FREE PRESS

FINANCIAL TIMES
FORBES

FORTUNE

HOLLYWOOD REPORTER

HOUSTON CHRONICLE
INVESTORS BUSINESS DAILY

INDIANAPOLIS STAR

KANSAS CITY STAR
L0S ANGELES TIMES

MIAMI HERALD

MILWAUKEE JOURNAL- SENTINEL

MINNEAPOLIS STAR- TRIBUNE

NATION
NATIONAL ENQUIRER
NATIONAL REVIEW
NEW JERSEY STAR-LEDGER

NEW REPUBLIC

NEW YORK

NEW YORK DLY NEWS
NEW YORK OBSERVER
NEW YORK POST
NEW YORK TIMES
NEW YORKER
NEWSWEEK

OREGONIAN

ORANGE COUNTY- REGISTER

ORLANDO SENTINEL
PEOPLE
PHILADELPHIA- INQUIRER
PHILADELPHIA DAILY NEWS

PITTSBURGH POST-GAZETTE

REASON MAG
ROLLING STONE

SACRAMENTO BEE

SAN ANTONIO EXP- NEWS

SAN DIEGO UNION-TRIB
SAN FRANCISCO- CHRONICLE

SAN JOSE MERCURY- NEWS
STAR

ST. LOUIS POST- DISPATCH

ST.PETERSBURG- TIMES
TIME

U.S. NEWS
USA TODAY
VANITY FAIR
VARIETY

VILLAGE VOICE

WALL STREET JNL
WASHINGTON POST
WASHINGTON TIMES
WEEKLY STANDARD

WIRED

 

INTL. PRINT SOURCES

AUSTRALIAN

CANADA GLOBE & MAIL

CANADA NATL POST

DER SPIEGEL INTL.

INDIA TIMES

INTL. HERALD TRIBUNE

IRISH TIMES

JERUSALEM POST

JOHANNESBURG STAR

KENYA DAILY NATION

MOSCOW TIMES

PAKISTAN DAWN

PAKISTAN NEWS INTL.

PRAVDA

S.A. MAIL&GUARDIAN

S.AFRICA TIMES

SYDNEY MORNING HERALD

TORONTO STAR

TORONTO SUN
[U.K.] DAILY MAIL
[U.K.] DAILY MIRROR
[U.K.] DAILY RECORD

[U.K.] ECONOMIST
[U.K.] EVENING STANDARD
[U.K.] EXPRESS
[U.K.] GUARDIAN
[U.K.] INDEPENDENT
[U.K.] NEWS OF THE WORLD

[U.K.] NEW STATESMAN

[U.K.] SCOTSMAN

[U.K.] SPECTATOR
[U.K.] SUN
[U.K.] TELEGRAPH
[U.K.] TIMES

VANCOUVER SUN

 

RADIO AND TV

ABC NEWS

AL JAZEERA

BBC
BBC VIDEO & AUDIO

BBC WORLD SERVICE

BLOOMBERG

CBC NEWS
CBS NEWS

CITADEL- BROADCASTING

CLEAR CHANNEL- RADIO
C-SPAN
CNN

CNN VIDEO & AUDIO

DAILY SHOW

ESPN
EW ENTERTAINMENT- WEEKLY
FOXNEWS
MSNBC

NPR

PBS

SKY NEWS

 

About Commentopia

A Digest of Best Readers' Comments curated from top news sites and blogs. READ MORE

Support Commentopia

 

 

Thank You for Your Support

 

Commentopia is an Amazon Affiliate site. If you click on a link to Amazon and buy an item there, a small portion of your purchase will go to supporting the curation of Commentopia.


 

@commentopia

Bookmark and Share

 

submit to reddit

Bloggers - Meet Millions of Bloggers

CONTACT

COMMENTOPIA

©2009-2011 COMMENTOPIA

 


advertisement

Riding the Rails: Teenagers on the Move During the Great Depression is a riveting document of hope and  hardship during one of this nation's bleakest eras.

Uys so thoroughly recreates the  wretched conditions the boxcar boys and girls endured  that the reader can all but hear the cadence of the  trains on the tracks and the lonesome wail at every  whistle stop. Boston Globe

An elegantly presented and quietly moving collection of firsthand reminiscences, capturing a unique moment in American history. Enthusiastically recommended.

-- Library Journal

One of the most poignant memories of the wandering youth of the Great Depression

-- Sacramento Bee

PRINT & KINDLE

 


 

WHAT DID THEY SAY?

 

WORLD

    2011

    December

    November

    October

    September

    August

   July  & earlier

NATIONAL

    2011

    December

    November

    October

    September

    August

    July & earlier

BUSINESS

   2011

   December

   November

   October

   September

   August

   July & earlier

HEALTH/EDUCATION

   2011

   December

   November

   October

   September

   August

   July & earlier

 

SCI/TECH

   2011

   December

   November

   October

   September

   August

   July & earlier

ENVIRONMENT/NATURE

   2011

   December

   November

   October

   September

   August

   July & earlier

ENTERTAINMENT/SPORTS

    2011

    December

    November

    October

    September

    August

    July & earlier

PEOPLE

   2011

   December

   November

   October

   September

   August

   July & earlier

 

 

COMMENTOPIA -- "THE BIG STORY, THE BEST COMMENTS"

 

A SERVICE BRINGING YOU THE BEST READERS' COMMENTS FROM TOP NEWS SOURCES ON THE WEB