commentopia What the World Is Saying A SERVICE BRINGING YOU THE BEST READERS' COMMENTS FROM TOP NEWS SOURCES ON THE WEB NATIONAL ARCHIVES — MAY 2010
[RETURN TO commentopia HOME PAGE]
MAY 24, 2010 -- MAY 30, 2010 PRIMARY LESSONS IN A LONG, HOT ELECTION SEASON
While I'm one who wants to "throw the bums out" and have been advocating that strategy for a very long time, I fear voters are choosing out of fear instead of informed consent. Read the article DAILY BEAST/Three lessons from today's election <> Dear Conservatives,, Please explain to me how Republicans are fiscally responsible. We saw national debt increase BTW, I voted for each of the Presidents I listed.. Read the article DAILY BEAST/Three lessons from today's election <> Eighty-year-old, thirty- year senator Spector was part of the problem, not part of the solution. We need to take back this country and return to the days of people being self sufficient and taking care of their own problems instead of looking to the Fed and States to solve them. We have completely lost the pioneer spirit that used to make this country GREAT. Now we are a bunch of whiners looking for a free dole at some other persons expense. I hope all the old timers in DC get a kick in the pants and voted OUT. Any senator or congressman who continues to vote in foolish programs like B.O.'s health care and bank bail outs and endless wars in Pakistan and so forth should be removed and plenty quick. Now is the time for the Tea Party voters to exercise their muscle. Maybe then the rest of the bums in DC will get the message LOUD and CLEAR. Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/Specter defeat signals a wave against incumbents
"It's not left-wing Democrats versus right-wing Republicans. It's the "Mad-As-Hell" Party against both." Read the article HUFFINGTON POST/Robert Reich - The Mad-As-Hell Party scores as the anxious class stews
MAY 10, 2010 -- MAY 23, 2010 THE BIG SPILL -- THE LONG STRAW AND OTHER SOLUTIONS
The whole world is watching to see what will happen, now that the big spill everyone has feared is pouring into the Gulf and American waters. Environmentalists, fishermen and beach resort owners, local and national governments, and oil producers (and oil market speculators) are all watching to see where the chips will fall. Read the article BBC/Mark Mardell's America: Maintaining the oil pressure
<> A lot of really big words and armchair quarter backs. Whether anyone likes it or not, oil makes the world go around. Petroleum is used in virtually every aspect of our lives and day to day activities. I am always amazed when I see the "Ban offshore drilling" bumper sticker....on a car that runs on oil products......and is built using petroleum based products. Parked in a garage built with materials hauled by fuel burning vessels from trans to planes. So before everyone jumps on the 'I hate big oil band wagon'....try and visualize how difficult life would be without it. Read the article YAHOO NEWS/Worry that Gulf oil spreading into major current <> "The point is, if you're going to be drilling in 5,000 feet of water for oil, you should have the ability to control what you're doing," Read the article YAHOO NEWS/Worry that Gulf oil spreading into major current <> ......."We've never seen anything like this before. It's impossible to fathom the impact."....... Read the article NPR/BP says tube is diverting some oil from well <> The government needs to ensure that there are no caps on the amount of money required to clean up this spill. Additionally, laws need to be changed so that when a company has a significant impact on the environment or a local economy, they must provide all data. They can't have ownership of the tapes from the underwater recordings or ownership of the files, which indicate they were aware of old batteries or didn't have the required maintenance on machinery or didn't follow safety protocols. We basically allowed the oil companies to run the game, just like we did with the financial companies and look at the mess both have gotten us into!!! Less government, Tea Party? Less government, Republicans? I think not! More efficient government - YES!!! Read the article DAILY BEAST/Oil spill reaches major current SUPREME COURT GIVES SOME YOUNG HOODLUMS A BREAK
Courts systems in general in this country are run by people who are so far removed from the society that generates citizens like Mr Graham. While I hate to stereotype, Mr Graham probably doesn't have a father figure in his life, reads at a very low level, and doesn't have much of a future in mind. The court system today is a way to avail ourselves from the social inequalities that exist today. Instead of looking at ways and spending tax dollars to improve the things that make a difference for young people like Mr. Graham, we spend money on keeping them locked up. To then add insult to injury, once we have someone like Mr. Graham off the streets, we do nothing to prepare this person to re-enter society. The SC's decision is a step in the right direction, but it will take much political will to make any changes to this system. Because prisons = jobs, jobs = votes, and votes = status quo. Read the article ECONOMIST/Life without parole for juveniles: Mercy for young thugs <> I did some pretty stupid stuff as a teenager. Things that I would never do today. To hold me fully accountable for that stuff would have destroyed my life. Thankfully I was able to afford a good lawyer, or things might have been a lot different. I hit a bunch of mailboxes and was later arrested for mushroom possession, neither of which should really be jailable offenses, but nonetheless I faced around 40 years of sentencing had it gone to trial. Pretty absurd for some stuff that caused no physical harm to any person. I did repay the people for their mailboxes. Read the article CNN/Life "cruel and unusual punishment for teens, court rules"
IS NEW SPACE PLAN ONE GIANT LEAP BACKWARD?
"Curiosity is the essence of human existence. Who are we? Where are we? Where do we come from? Where are we going? ... I don't know. I don't have any answers to those questions. I don't know what's over there around the corner. But I want to find out. It's within our hearts and souls and desires to find out and seek knowledge. Discovery is what it's all about." -- Eugene Cernan, Time The Hubble Space Telescope as an argument for manned space flight, just doesn't add up. The HST cost around $2.5B to construct (this cost was probably raised by the need for the telescope to be serviceable in orbit). Read the article NEW SCIENTIST/Neil Armstrong criticizes new space plan in Congress <> I think it's pointless to rely on any government anymore for an initiative in space. The space was never important to politicians, even for JFK, who said that if he had a cheaper and Earth-based alternative to space race with the Russians he would much prefer that one then push for the Moon. When the first bunch of people succeeds to land on an asteroid and become very rich owners of a huge mountain of almost pure Fe and Ni or something similar - that's when the real space race will kick in. Read the article THE REGISTER/Neil Armstrong renews attack on Obama space vision. <> It's not as though the United States does not have several heavy lift rockets that are in production, have proven records, and could be adapted to human launch. Besides, what we really need is a infrastructure system to get to the Moon, and Mars. Think "Transcontinental Railway" instead of "Lewis and Clark Expedition. Read the article THE REGISTER/Neil Armstrong renews attack on Obama space vision. <> The Russians and Chinese aren't taking over space.
Read the article FLORIDA TODAY/Space pioneers criticize budget
ELENA KAGAN: A NOMINEE FROM OUTSIDE THE "JUDICIAL MONASTERY"
Many of the finest justices have never previously been judges. Think of John Marshall, Salmon P. Chase, Hugo Black, and, most important, Earl Warren, widely regarded as our greatest Chief Justice and a man responsible for shepherding a unanimous decision on Brown v. Board. The trend, and it's only a recent trend, of appointing sitting judges has in no way been an improvement. The quality of the individual justices has fallen and the quality of the high court as a group and its opinions have declined precipitously. There is now a narrow ideological rigidity that didn't exist previously. Read the article SAN FRANCISCO CHRONICLE/ Elena Kagan chosen by Obama for Supreme Court <> There is a serious problem brewing with the nomination of Supreme Court Justices. It's not a conservative v. liberal issue, nor is it Democrat v. Republican. It's not even about abortion rights. <> Her arguments in the Rasul v Rumsfeld made me sick to my stomach. She WILL move the court to the right on the things I care about most - executive power grabs and separation of powers. I could care less about her hiring record at Harvard. An awful pick. The right gets Alito and Roberts, two unapologetic right wingers, when they had a 54-46 majority. We get Kagan when there were other excellent choices, especially Judge Wood, and we have a 59-41 majority. But nominating and confirming Wood would have taken some spine, something Democrats, with a few exceptions, don't have. Read the article DAILY KOS/Obama to announce Kagan pick <> President Obama's proposed nomination of Solicitor General Elena Kagan to the Supreme Court is a fine choice. As the article stated, she is a well-regarded - as well as well-rounded - attorney, having worked in all 3 branches of government. Although she has no prior judicial experience, she also has not been cloistered as a sitting judge. Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/Obama chooses Kagan, scholar but not judge, for court seat $10 MILLION A DAY OIL SPILL BATTLE FALTERS IN THE DEEP
Where is Red Adair when you need him? Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/Problem for containment dome in Gulf
This is a time tested approach, the only problem is, it has never been attempted, much less tested at this depth. The same technique has been used many times before, at much lower depths, and for the most part results were good. Read the article CNN/Containment dome arrives at gushing oil well site <> Gas hydrates are methane (natural gas) surrounded by water molecules in a gel-like slush. At higher temperatures and lower pressures the explosive methane is freed. (Methane hydrate thawing is occuring in the arctic, contributing to accelerated atmospheric warming. Methane is much worse than carbon dioxide as a greenhouse gas.) So BP is between a rock and a hard place. The hydrates are messy and explosive. (Rapid hydrate decomposition may have been the reason for the initial explosion.) The crude petroleum is nasty, smelly stuff in it's own right. But it is clear that the "Drill, baby, drill" chorus needs to cease until the technology catches up with the chemistry, physics, and engineering. Meanwhile, where are Exxon, Shell and the rest? Can't they help? Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/Problem for containment dome in Gulf
<> It seems to me that nobody really knows how much pressure this deposit is under. Some industry experts are claiming that the blowout preventer failed open because the valve simply cannot handle the wellhead pressure, which may be substantially higher than anticipated. Read the article HUFFINGTON POST/100-Ton-concrete-and-steel contraption hauled to well ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION -- LOOKING AT THE BROADER ISSUES
I am a longtime resident of Phoenix, Arizona. About a third of my neighbors are of some degree of Hispanic origin. Much more than ten percent of my neighbors are gay. My barber is from Iraq. My cardiologist is Pakistani, my General Practitioner is a born again Christian woman. My closest friend is Jewish, another is a Christian Navajo, and I am an Atheist. How dare you try to lecture residents of Arizona about getting along with people different than them. This state has a long tradition of being a melting pot. This state, also, has a long tradition of people getting along with each other. We just want the never-ending stream -- no river -- of people , coming here illegally and staying, to stop. Now, if your Governor, Frank, says that we can provide illegal immigrants with a one-way ticket to New York; then maybe our problem will be resolved. But, frankly, we can't handle the overload anymore. President Obama needs to stop campaigning and playing golf long enough to do the job for which he was elected. Once the borders are sealed and protected, then we, in Arizona, can go back to living our very tolerant and diverse lives in peace. Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/Frank Rich -- "If Only Arizona Were the Real Problem" <> The 5000 pound gorilla in the room is the "illegal employer" aspect of this very real problem. Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/Frank Rich -- "If Only Arizona Were the Real Problem" <> Reform is needed...in Mexico! I do mission work in very poor areas of Mexico. Mexicans are not proud about fleeing North. They want an effective government, and safe streets, they do not want to be forced to flee their own country. Protesting on the streets of the U.S. is myopic at best...the protest should be on the streets of Mexico City. Read the article HUFFINGTON POST/Arizona immigration law spawns panicky exaggerations.
The notion that anyone living on the U.S.-Mexico border would think a person was in the United States illegally simply because they look Hispanic is ludicrous. The border is Hispanic. The population of large border cities like El Paso, with a population of about 750,000, is about 85 percent Hispanic-American. Anglo-American, not Hispanic-Americans, look out of place. The police forces are overwhelming Hispanic. They suspect people may be illegal aliens when they don't speak English, are wearing clothes manufactured in Mexico, speak Spanish with a South American or Central American accents, and have no drivers' license or other form of identification. Read the article HUFFINGTON POST/Arizona immigration lawsuits:Tucson, Flagstaff councils vote to sue
MAY 3, 2010 -- MAY 9, 2010 REFLECTIONS ON THE PLOT TO BOMB TIMES SQUARE
THE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT U.S. VS SHAHZAD I have always tried to be tolerant of other people's beliefs. From the conservative Jewish father who was upset when his daughter was living with me after college, to a friend down in Georgia whose family tried to get me "saved" when he took me home for a hunting trip; to a current Mormon neighbor who advises me to stock up a year's worth of food.. Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/N.Y. bomb suspect said to implicate self <> Many other nations, including developed nations like Spain and the UK, have dealt with multiple terrorist attacks per decade. The first thing Americans need to realize is that the US is not special for coming under attacks. We have enemies, they have an agenda, and they recruit crazy people to blow things up. Read the article NPR/Bomb suspect nabbed while trying to leave U.S. The blame game on here is a sad statement regarding our society. If someone wants to fall off the radar screen and do something, it isn't that hard. We want our freedoms and we want to be safe, these 2 things are often in conflict with each other. There is a balance to it all. Guy spends years functioning in our society, and then things go South and he goes off the deep end. There is a balance to it all, and we are truly blessed as a society that it doesn't happen more often, and at the same time we all retain a modicum of freedom. So stop blaming Obama, the CIA, Bush, the FBI, etc. We are lucky this guy was borderline incompetent at creating a b0mb. I doubt we will be as lucky next time, and yet I am sure we will all rush to blame someone all the while developing some type of conspiracy theory. Read the article HUFFINGTON POST/How Faisal Shahzad was caught <> Pretending that somehow this is a great success of the DOJ, Homeland Security and the FBI is absurd. A slight more intelligent terrorist and a few more seconds of time are all it would have taking to make this "foiled attack" a huge success. The government had no role whatsoever in preventing this act of senseless violence against the civilian populace. It was private citizens who discovered the activity and reported it. Blaming the airlines is just another sad example of this administration's blame-storming and abdication of responsibly. The American people deserve better. Read the article NEW YORK TIMES/Lapses allowed suspect to board plane "PREPARE FOR THE WORST" --FACING A REAL AND PRESENT CATASTROPHE IN THE GULF
Considering the record profits oil companies have been making for the last several years it shouldn't be any hardship at all for them to pay into this fund, but you just know they'll be screaming about how poor they are as soon as this becomes law. It will be interesting to see how forthcoming BP will be with funding the clean up of their mess. Meanwhile the massive oil slick gets nearer to the Louisiana & Florida coastlines. Entire industries, such as shrimping, fishing, and raising oysters will be devastated for decades to come. Will BP compensate the people who made their living on the now ruined waterways of the Gulf States? How about the tourism industries? Can the economic impact of this disaster even be determined and what compensation will those hurt by the oily beaches & water get? How's that "Drill baby Drill" chant sound now? Read the article CNN POLITICAL TICKER/ Senator: 'BP says it'll pay for this mess. Baloney.' <> I live on the west coast of Florida in an old fishing village, Tarpon Springs. In 1993, there was an oil spill (223,000 gallons of #6 crude) off St Pete Beach, 25 miles south of here. It took several years to clean up the mess and even 5-10 years later, after a storm on the Gulf, tar balls would wash up on the beach. This leak is 210,000 gallons PER DAY. They say proudly that they have already removed "a quarter million gallons of 'oily water'".. oil mixed with water.. They are not even staying even with the leak. The economy of Florida is largely dependent upon tourism and fishing. The lack of preparation and cavalier attitude of BP shows their disregard for the people in the quest for the almighty $. Our government allows, even promotes that thinking. The "Drill, baby, drill" mentality promoted by some politicians would allow drilling as close as 10 miles from shore. One cannot even imagine the disaster if this had happened 10 miles offshore. Read the article BBC-HAVE YOUR SAY/Is enough being done to prevent environmental disasters?
I am not a member of the Sierra Club and I am in favor of drilling offshore and I oppose Cap & Trade. That information notwithstanding, if this oil continues to flow uninterrupted and continues to spread toward the shores of Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, and Northwest Florida, this will be a disaster of epic proportions. This is NOT a political debate. Read the article WALL STREET JOURNAL/Oil spill likely to reach land in days <> As an avowed environmentalist, I have come to support increased drilling as an element of our overall strategy, combined with increased efficiency, use of renewable energy, natural gas and nuclear. This is based on the repeated assertions of the pro drilling contingent that we can now drill safely and cleanly and we should loosen the restrictions. I feel like a fool now - at least 10 people have lost their life, and the coasts of Florida and Louisiana may soon be blanketed with oil, which would be an economic and environmental disaster (not yet but we'll know in a few days). Are our SUVs and insatiable energy needs really worth this? Read the article WALL STREET JOURNAL/Oil spill likely to reach land in days
The obvious aside, who's going to pay for all of this? Not just the cost of plugging the hole, cleaning the spill, wildlife rescue, and lawsuits, but all of the little costs, to the little guy and the small business owners that operate in the resort communities along the coast? What about all of the lost revenue to the local government budgets? Who's going to pay for that? These people are already stretched thin. I guess the federal government will have to step in, and cover the oil companies and their insurance companies at the taxpayer's expense, right? This is why I say end limited liability laws for management and major shareholders. Hold them personally responsible. I'm not talking about widows and pension funds, I'm talking about the shareholders who have a vote in management decisions. That would definitely make people think long and hard about their decisions. If individuals are not held responsible, then reckless behavior will continue, especially when the taxpayer is footing the bill. Read the article DAILY BEAST/Gulf oil spill to reach land <> As a former news reporter who covered South Louisiana and wrote stories on offshore oil rig blowouts, I am absolutely amazed over how British Petroleum has been able to spoon-feed their version of the Deepwater Horizon catastrophe in the Gulf of Mexico. Further, I am amazed over how the White House, the U.S. Coast Guard, the Environmental Protection Agency and NOAA have allowed British Petroleum to woefully minimize this catastrophe for so long a time. Case in point: we just "learned" late yesterday that there was "a second leak" from the floor of the Gulf, and that the outflow into the Gulf is 5,000 barrels instead of 1,000 barrels per day. This morning we read where apparently there is "a third leak" from the floor of the Gulf. Now how can this be? Simply because these types of platforms are used to drill multiple wellheads on the ocean floor--as many as a dozen or more for obvious reasons: to extract the oil more quickly and economically and increase profits. So, Associated Press, New York Times, Washington Post, CBS, NBC, ABC, CNN, etc. , please ask your reporters why they haven't "discovered" this fact, and demand that they get off their butts and begin doing some legwork instead of relying on British Petroleum's "spoon-fed news"! Read the article TIMES-PICAYUNE/Five times as much oil spilling into Gulf of Mexico as first thought X-37B -- U.S. AIR FORCE LAUNCHES "MINI-ME" SHUTTLE
Space has been militarized for decades with communication and reconnaissance satellites and a few outright weapons. Deal with it. Read the article HUFFINGTON POST/Boeing X37 launches on secretive Air Force mission <> For all the wild-eyed ranters: Read the article HUFFINGTON POST/Boeing X37 launches on secretive Air Force mission
read more comments from THE INDEX © 2009-2010 Commentopia |